Thank you reviewer 3

I have heard PhD students are typically harsher reviewers for academic manuscripts than established researchers. They look for reasons to reject a paper, while more experienced reviewers look for reasons to accept. I lack the experience to say how true this is, but it makes intuitive sense to me. Academia can be a rough place. Method papers describe how perfectly executed studies should look, reading only accepted publications in top venues creates the impression that is how every paper must be and reviewer responses can be devastating....

November 12, 2023 · 2 min · 288 words · Philip Heltweg

A Systematic Analysis of Problems in Open Collaborative Data Engineering

Our paper “A Systematic Analysis of Problems in Open Collaborative Data Engineering” got accepted to the ACM Transactions on Social Computing (ACM-TSC). Abstract Collaborative workflows are common in open-source software development. They reduce individual costs and improve the quality of work results. Open data shares many characteristics with open-source software as it can be used, modified, and redistributed by anyone, for free. However, in contrast to open-source software engineering, collaborative data engineering on open data lacks a shared understanding of processes, methods, and tools....

October 30, 2023 · 2 min · 241 words · Philip Heltweg

AI-powered local interview transcription with Whisper

The problem Interviews are great. You can learn a lot about a topic by talking to experts. If you are working on a product, talking to users is common advice. If you are a researcher, qualitative surveys using interviews are great fun. Transcribing interviews, however, sucks Doing it yourself is tedious and is a painfully acquired skill. Outsourcing work to one of the various transcription APIs also is no perfect solution....

May 6, 2023 · 2 min · 325 words · Philip Heltweg

Write an exposé for your thesis

I ask students that want to write a thesis with me to prepare an exposé (or project outline) before we start. For the student, this ensures they have an idea of the work involved and a reasonable timeline to complete it. For me, it provides a short overview about what we agreed on and highlights important deadlines. At a minimum, I think an exposé should be a roughly two-page PDF and include:...

February 13, 2023 · 4 min · 691 words · Philip Heltweg

Challenges to Open Collaborative Data Engineering

Our paper “Challenges to Open Collaborative Data Engineering” got accepted to the Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences 2023 (HICSS 56). Sadly, we could not present in person due to a flight cancellation but we provided a short video presentation. Abstract Open data is data that can be used, modified, and passed on, for free, similar to open-source software. Unlike open-source, however, there is little collaboration in open data engineering. We perform a systematic literature review of collaboration systems in open data, specifically for data engineering by users, taking place after data has been made available as open data....

January 3, 2023 · 1 min · 173 words · Philip Heltweg

Softwarecampus 2022 - How to run a kickoff event for nerds

At the start of July, I visited the Softwarecampus Kickoff Event. The Softwarecampus is a project targeting self-described “EntrepreNerds” and sponsoring research projects with an industry partner with up to 100k€. Having been to a few ice-breaker events with fellow nerds I anticipated an awkward day but I was pleasantly surprised. In the hope of being pleasantly surprised again in the future, I wanted to share some ways the Softwarecampus team made the event stand out to me....

August 22, 2022 · 3 min · 467 words · Philip Heltweg

Master Thesis: Implementing a Structured Approach to Belief Revision by Deterministic Switching Between Total Preorders

Abstract Belief change research investigates how agents adapt their knowledge with potentially conflicting information. A common formalization is by epistemic states, abstract entities often represented by faithful preorders. Operators describe how epistemic states change with new evidence and are classified by which postulates they satisfy. Different approaches have been suggested for the problem of iterated belief change. Recent work introduces uniform revision that revises an agent’s beliefs based on one static total preorder, therefore lowering representational costs....

November 7, 2021 · 1 min · 175 words · Philip Heltweg

Certification of Iterated Belief Changes via Model Checking and its Implementation

Note: An extended version of this paper has been published at the 7th Workshop on Formal and Cognitive Reasoning, you can find it here. Our paper “Certification of Iterated Belief Changes via Model Checking and its Implementation” got accepted to the 19th International Workshop on Non-Monotonic Reasoning (NMR-2021) at the 18th International Conference on Principles of Knowledge Representation and Reasoning (KR 2021). During the workshop I held a short presentation of the results....

October 27, 2021 · 2 min · 228 words · Philip Heltweg

On Using Model Checking for the Certification of Iterated Belief Changes

Our paper “On Using Model Checking for the Certification of Iterated Belief Changes” got accepted to the 7th Workshop on Formal and Cognitive Reasoning (FCR-2021) at the 44th German Conference on Artificial Intelligence (KI-2021). During the workshop I held a short presentation of the results. You can find both the paper as well as the presentation slides here. Abstract The theory of iterated belief change investigates how epistemic states are changed according to new beliefs....

September 28, 2021 · 2 min · 229 words · Philip Heltweg

Of judges, aliens and total preorders

I created this synopsis of some ideas from the paper “How to Revise a Total Preorder” by Booth and Meyer during the seminar on “Representation and processing of uncertain knowledge with logic-based methods” at the University of Hagen. The slides are from my final presentation of the topic (and might be more or less useless on their own). Abstract Adapting one’s world view in the light of new information is a central skill of intelligent agents....

April 9, 2021 · 1 min · 179 words · Philip Heltweg